Welcome to Butterfingers Munster
Butterfingers Munster, located in the heart of Munster, IN, is a cherished specialty food gem that beautifully marries the nostalgia of homemade meals with a touch of culinary innovation. Known for its rich array of baked goods and hearty deli selections, this charming establishment offers a delightful experience, from their out-of-this-world chocolate fudge brownies to the praises of their deep dish peach pie. Customers rave about the flavorful entrees and exemplary customer service, making it the perfect spot for lunch or a sweet treat. Here, each dish echoes the warmth of home cooking, inviting guests to savor memorable flavors with every bite.
- 921 Ridge Rd, Munster, IN 46321 Hotline: (219) 836-4202
Welcome to Butterfingers Munster, a delightful specialty food destination nestled in the heart of Munster, Indiana. Located at 921 Ridge Rd, this charming bakery and deli has become a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike. Renowned for its delectable offerings, Butterfingers Munster masterfully blends homemade comfort food with artisanal bakery items, creating a menu that leaves you both satisfied and craving more.
As you step through the doors, you are greeted with the sweet aroma of freshly baked goods and the inviting hustle of a bustling kitchen. The ambiance exudes warmth, reminiscent of afternoons spent in a cherished grandmother's kitchen. Each dish served here tells a story of careful preparation and an unchanged desire to provide joy with every bite.
- Stuffed Red Peppers - A standout entrée here is the stuffed red peppers, where tender chicken breast is paired with sour cream and breadcrumbs, transforming a simple dish into a comforting delight priced at $8.25.
- Box and Bag Lunches - For those seeking a quick meal, the box lunches offer a delightful selection. Choose from hearty sandwiches or large wraps, complete with sides and sweet treats, all for $12.25.
- Fresh Salads - Refreshing options like the fresh fruit salad ($7.75) and red bliss potato salad ($7.50) are perfect companions to any meal, providing a balance of flavors that are both vibrant and satisfying.
- Bakery Highlights - Patrons rave about the chocolate fudge brownie and the peach pie, with reviews describing them as heavenly and the best they've ever tasted. The deep dish peach pie, filled with quality fruit and a perfect gel consistency, truly is a masterpiece.
Not only is the food a triumph, but the service shines just as bright. The staff—described as friendly and accommodating—are eager to help you navigate the delightful menu, ensuring you leave with a happy heart and satisfied palate. Customers like Krystle Fuller have shared how hospitable the team is, making each visit memorable for families and individuals alike.
In a world of fast-food chains and impersonal dining experiences, Butterfingers Munster stands out. It’s a hidden gem where every pastry and sandwich whispers tales of homemade love and attention to detail. Whether you’re picking up lunch, dining in for a cozy afternoon, or planning for a special occasion with their delightful cakes, you will find a piece of culinary heaven in every visit.
So, if you find yourself in the Munster area, make it a point to stop by Butterfingers Munster. It promises an experience that is not just a meal but a delightful escape into the world of specialty foods that feel like home.

The chocolate fudge brownie tastes like heaven!!! Great lunch spot as well as picking up some entrees or salads for dinner...

THE BEST PEACH PIE IVE EVER EATEN. I do not say that lightly. Its deep dish and filled with quality fruit. I didnt get any bitter or hard peach and there was enough gel that it was flavorful and moist, but not overwhelming. The crust is ...

Purchased a cake for a birthday and it was delicious! White Chocolate Strawberry flavor! I will definitely be back!!

This cake it might be the strawberry pound cake, Im not too sure is insane. I dont understand how it can look so dense and yet melt like cotton candy... And the icing is whipped cream based but its so flavorful. Its a dream to eat. ...

I recently visited Butterfingers on a Wednesday afternoon in search of a sweet treat to satiate any potential cravings. My eyes were immediately drawn to the vanilla cupcakes, and let me tell you, these were some of the most phenomenal ...

Food was delicious and freshly prepared. Service was fast and friendly. This is a hidden little gem! Highly recommend the chicken salad sandwich!

Has the best customer service from 3 awesome ladies. I went in with my 6 year old daughter. They were patient as she picked out a cookie, helped each other out and were so polite and professional. Another guest came in as we were eating and ...

Wow Impressed by the service and food quality!! the best in the Region from bakery to the deli sandwiches felt like i went back in time to my grandmothers kitchen!! Highly recommend if your in town or passing by!